Were the 1943 Grays better than the 1927 Yankees?

The 1927 Yankees went 110–44 behind Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig, and they're the usual answer to "greatest team of all time." The 1943 Homestead Grays went 78–23–1 with Josh Gibson, Buck Leonard and Cool Papa Bell, in the middle of nine straight Negro National League pennants. The two teams played 16 years apart and never met.

So we played it out. Rubber Match is a baseball simulation built on real career statistics, adjusted so players from different eras can share a field. We put each team at its best, played a full 162-game season between them, and then did it 600 times.

The Grays won the season 68% of the time. The Yankees won 27%, and the other 5% finished tied at 81–81. The Grays' average record was 85–77.

Here is one of those seasons from start to finish. The Grays go 87–75.

Watch on YouTube

How it works

Every at-bat is calculated from the specific matchup, accounting for the career stats of each batter, pitcher, and defensive player in the field. The math accounts for how the same matchup plays out differently as games and seasons unfold — so no matchup is ever the same in a single season. Every player is put on one modern scale using Full House Modeling (Eck, Annals of Applied Statistics, 2025). The Grays' numbers are estimates built from Eric Chalek's Major League Equivalencies, which translate Negro Leagues records into major league terms.

The title

Each month a new legendary team plays the reigning champion. The '27 Yankees held the title against the '06 Cubs and the '12 Red Sox. The Grays are the first team to take it from the Yankees. The '54 Indians are up next in December.

Take on the '43 Grays

They're November's Legendary team. Draft your own roster from 400+ legends and play them over 162 games. It's free, with no login.

PLAY RUBBER MATCH

Credits: Full House Modeling · Eric Chalek · Seamheads · Lahman · Retrosheet · Baseball-Reference · Data & Credits